Distributed Generation
Solar Electricity Prices
Solar Industry Statistics
Home
Distributed Generation

Distributed Power Generation: compare Solar Energy with alternative energy sources


Solar Energy is often talked of in the context of other Renewable Energy technologies that also have Distributed Energy Generation potential. Distributed Generation is defined as the generation of energy close to the point of use.  Distributed generation typically ranges from 1 kilowatt to 5 Megawatts in capacity. This contrasts with Central Generation, which is associated with large 500 to 3000 Megawatt generating plants that are usually located at a distance from where the energy is consumed. The electricity is then transported through the transmission and distribution infrastructure to the customer/user.

Distributed generation has these advantages:

  •  it can reduce or avoid the necessity to build new transmission/distribution lines or upgrade existing ones
  •  it can be configured to meet peak power needs
  •  it can diversify the range of energy sources in use and increase the reliability of the grid network
  •  it can be configured to provide premium power, when coupled with uninterruptible power supply (UPS)
  •  it is well-suited to the use of some renewable energy technologies, because they can be located close to the user and can be installed in small increments to match the load requirement of the customer.

When comparing the costs of different energy sources, an "apples to apples" comparison is not straightforward for the following reasons:

  • power stations are major increments of power, which does not easily make for comparison with distributed energy, which is installed in relatively small increments.

  • the cost of finance is critical to renewable energy sources. Energy sources that utilize fossil fuels have both upfront costs and ongoing costs (i.e. the cost of purchasing oil, gas), which means that a substantial part of their total costs are spread over time. In contrast, Renewable energy typically incurs a high upfront cost, but sees extremely low ongoing costs. This means that a low cost of finance amortized over the life of the equipment/capital investment can vastly enhance the economics of renewable energy.

  • dispatchability has value. If the energy supply is "dispatchable", it means the energy supply is guaranteed or predictable. The more predictable it is, the higher its value. Fossil fuel driven power plants and nuclear power are dispatchable. Renewable energy sources alone are generally not. Therefore to make an "apples to apples' to comparison, the renewable energy sources must be configured with a means of "energy storage" (i.e. batteries or hybrid systems (renewable energy and another energy source)) to create a true comparison.

  • fit with load curve. An energy source that produces at the time of high demand (over a 24 hour period) has greater value to both the Utility and the Customer. Periods of peak load are the most expensive time because the Utility has to have that capacity available, yet that same capacity will remain idle during other parts of the day. Solar Energy is a good fit with daily load peaks where summer air conditioning is required and does not need to be "dispatchable" as it can pass surplus power back to the grid during the day, while drawing on the grid at night. This approach maximizes the value, while minimizing the cost of Solar Energy.

  • the economics of many renewables are dependent upon location and therefore can vary dramatically. Wind requires certain minimum speeds, solar economics can be optimized in regions of the world with good sunlight conditions. So a single cost per kilowatt hour can be misleading and the answer should be presented in the form of cost ranges.


So, with these caveats, the table below compares both the Fossil Fuel and Renewable Energy sources in a distributed energy application. The table includes Solar Energy (Photovoltaics), Fuels Cells, Microturbines, Wind Turbines, and Internal Combustion Engines.

The two key business issues for the growth of distributed energy are:
  • continued decline in the cost of distributed energy technologies
  • co-operation from Utilities and local Governments firstly to ensure the appropriate physical infrastructure to accept distributed generation in to the electricity grid, and secondly to facilitate the development of reasonable Connection Agreements.
Energy Source
Description
Typical Installation Size
Cost per kilowatt peak and per kilowatt hour*
Dispatchable?
Typical Uses
Solar Energy (Photovoltaics) A cell which converts the solar energy of the sun directly in to electricity
1-100 kilowatts
$6-10,000 per kWp or 20-40 cents per kWh
No
Baseload power source.

Off Grid homes, Remote Industrial Applications (e.g. telecommunication), road signage.
Microturbines A relatively new technology, which is just making the transition to commercial markets. Microturbines can run on a variety of fuels, including natural gas, propane, and fuel oil.  They consist of a compressor, combustor, turbine and generator. These very small turbines contain essentially one moving part and use either air or oil for lubrication. Microturbines require little maintenance, but need a major $10,000 overhaul every four years.

30-300 kilowatts
$1,000 to $1,500 per installed kWp or 10 to 15 cents per kWh
Yes
Can be used in baseload, peaking or co-generation applications.
Fuel cells In fuel cells, hydrogen and oxygen are separated by an electrolyte - inducing an electrochemical potential. This potential is converted into direct current electricity by protons moving through the electrolyte (combining with oxygen to form water) and electrons flowing through a separate electrical circuit.

Fuel cell types include phosphoric aid, molten carbonate, solid oxide and proton exchange membrane. Only phosphoric acid fuels cells are available commercially. Fuels cells can be fueled by natural gas, hydrogen, biogas or propane. However, hydrogen is the most used fuel source, which is usually extracted from natural gas.

Companies developing products for utilities and electric customers are concentrating on fuel cells that run on natural gas, but the automobile industry is investigating models that would run on gasoline or methanol.
1-200 kilowatts $3-4,000 per kWp or 10-15 cents per kWh
Yes
Rural (off-grid) power. Transportation. Appropriate for baseload applications.
Wind Turbines

Wind turbines are packaged systems that include the rotor, generator, turbine blades, and drive or coupling device.

The wind turns the blades of a windmill-like machine. The rotating blades turn the shaft to which they are attached. The turning shaft typically either powers a pump or turns a generator which produces electricity.

Selection of a suitable site is key to the economics of wind energy. In general, winds exceeding 5 m/s (11 mph) are required for cost-effective application of small grid-connected wind machines, while windfarms require wind speeds of 6 m/s (13 mph). For applications that are not grid-connected, of course, these requirements may vary, depending on the other power alternatives available and their costs.

10 kilowatt -2 Megawatt $1500-$3000 KWp

5-10 cents per kWh
(lower numbers associated with larger Wind Farms).

However, installed cost per kilowatt figures for wind turbines are somewhat misleading because of the low capacity factor of wind turbines (i.e. the ratio of actual energy produced by a power plant to the energy that would be produced if it operated at rated capacity for an entire year)
No
Homes and farms Process industries Remote communities

Most larger wind turbine farms facilities have energy characteristics closer to "central energy' than "distributed energy". Albeit the small wind turbines in the 25-100kW area are often configured in a system with solar energy and battery systems.
Internal combustion engines Includes diesel engines, natural gas engines. 50 kilowatt to 5 Megawatt $400-900 per KWp
Yes
Well-established, long history as back up or peaking applications
           
Central Power Generation Fossil fuel Power Stations 500-3000 Megawatt $500-1000 per kWp
Yes
Baseload/peaking electricity generation
* note the ratio of kilowatt peak to kilowatt hours will vary from one energy type to another, since this is dependent upon output (load factor) and also the operating costs of each technology are different.
Links to useful sites
More information on Fuel Cells http://www.fuelcells.org
Commercial site on Fuel Cells http://www.plugpower.com/
More information on Fuel Cells http://www.fuelcellworld.org
Fuel cell internet information portal http://www.fuelcelltoday.com
Gas Research Institute on Distributed Energy http://www.gri.org/pub/solutions/dg/
European Wind Energy Association http://www.ewea.org
American Wind Energy Association http://www.awea.org
US Government Department of Energy Distributed Power site http://www.eren.doe.gov/distributedpower/
Capstone Turbine - commercial site on Microturbines http://www.capstoneturbine.com/
H Power Corporation - a commercial site on Hydrogen fuel cells http://hpower.com/
Distributed Generation

© 2006 Solarbuzz, LLC. All rights reserved.